Your Qna     New Questions     About Qna
EQNA is a growing interactive people-knowledge network with more than 120,000 questions and 450,000 answers from over 55,000 members worldwide. With all friendly functions, EQNA will be a fun place to join, share and discover knowledge, an open net space allowing you to connect with other people having specialized knowledge or ones with same interests to yours. EQNA login features secured logins using Twitter and Facebook enable you to place questions without sharing your personal information to us. Lets get out and join our community today!
Ask a Question
BLUE CAFE

Why is it illegal to grow your own tobacco

What is the logic behind this law? Does it infringe on our personal liberty & freedom?
Willow:

HI Ant, I think that it is legal in the USA... what I found when I searched is that in 2005, some restrictions were lifted. It had to do with quotas, but in the process, it made it legal for the end user to grow their own.
If the law has changed since then, could you provide a link?
In case you are looking to grow your own, I found a good link:
http://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/AA260

BLUE CAFE:

Great. Thanks Willow. Actually I'm from Australia & I *assumed* we'd have similar laws on the subject but I guess I was wrong about that.
Thanks for the link & answer though. Appreciate it :)

Willow:

The logic behind the old restrictions was based on quotas and I am sure that price protection had everything to do with it. Manipulating the free market to keep prices up.
Yep, it did infringe upon personal freedom. When laws are created, somebody's personal liberties gets stepped upon. I reckon that there are times that for the greater good, it makes sense, but it has gone way beyond that.

Marebear79:

I thought a permit is only required if you grow tabacco for sale.

http://home.ktc.com/bdrake/faqs.html#twelve

BLUE CAFE:

Right, I see. I'm from Australia. I thought the laws may be the same but I guess they're not.
Thanks very much for your answer though

M60a3:

For the same reason you cannot distill your own whiskey. It is a taxed item. Taxes must be paid on every drop of whiskey that is distilled, and taxes must be paid on every leaf of tobacco that is grown.

This is why that by the time you purchase a bottle of whiskey or buy a package of cigarettes you are paying mostly taxes on them. If tobacco was not taxed we would pay less than a dollar for a pack of cigarettes.

BLUE CAFE:

So in the US it's still illegal to grow your own tobacco?
your answer makes a lot of sense. Thanks for that.
I still think though that it infringes on the rights of the individual his/her personal pursuit of happiness.

Steve:

then explain to me why wine and beer can be made at home. For these two are taxed items, No. This answer doesn't make sense to me when I look at these facts.

BLUE CAFE:

Thanks for the clarification 157. That makes more sense ;)

BLUE CAFE:

haha! No worries. At least now i dig where you're coming from with it.
I often forget myself that QnA is a US' centric site. it's a WWWorld!

BLUE CAFE:

Sorry, that was meant to read a Wide Wide WWWorld...

Joan:

I never new it was illegal to grow your own tobacco. i do not think you correct about that. u might not be abe to sell the end product. its not cannabis.

BLUE CAFE:

Thanks Chiba, I think you're right about that.

Steve:

Tobacco is a very easy plant to grow and requires only 65-70 frost free nights to mature once transplanted outside. It is grown in every state, even Alaska. In the U.S.A. it is legal to grow and process your own tobacco at home. Please check your local laws if living outside the U.S.A. DUH

RJ:

good

BLUE CAFE:

Thanks 157

RJ:

jim is right someone wants your money. it can't be taxed if you grow it yourself.

Ed:

Because you have to be rich in order to receive the tobacco subsidies.

?SugarBabe:

I have never heard that. I remember as a child visiting my grandmother in NW WI, she had a large old barn on her property that a neighbor used to dry tobacco leaves he had grown. This was many years ago. I guess you are saying it is no longer legal. I don't know why unless the government is worried about people selling it and not paying taxes on the product as is done with cigs. $

Answer:
Text ColorBackground Color
BoldItalicUnderline
LeftCenterRightJustify
Ordered ListBulleted List
IndentOutdent
Horizontal Rule
SubscriptSuperscript
HyperlinkImage
Design ModeDesign
Html ModeHtml
 

Top Question And Answer

  • Have you been illegal? What did you do?
  • Does Hillary really think she has a chance Or is it just her money talkin Illegal gains? crooked ?
  • If a co-worker approached you and told you something in confidence about his illegal addiction
  • isnt it illegal for an company to not pay you on time?
  • is it illegal 4 a collection agency 2 contact people on my long distance bill 2 try 2 contact me
  • Is it illegal to watch movies over the internet that are still in theaters?
  • One copy of Windows Vista Business....two pc's. Illegal? What would happen if I installed on both?
  • Do any illegal immigrants need a job? Harris Baking Company in Rogers, AR is hiring!
  • girls sell books door to door. illegal,scam. tells all need is 4 moore.trip to paris.whats up?
  • Who would best represent America as President- openly gay, illegal immigrant, divorced, or agonistic
  • Immigration Bill - How many of the 12 million illegal immigrants are.....
  • Did you know that in California it is illegal to park your car in a UNmarked crosswalk?
  • i want to open a discount tobacco store where can i find a tobacco distributer
  • where is the uk office of jt international the tobacco manufacturer
  • Do they grow coffee, tobacco, potatoes in Dirty Ankle, NC?
  • effects of chewing tobacco have on plant germination
  • Is tobacco a harmless drug?
  • Could you compare the oil companies to that of tobacco companies?
  • Does advertising distort our economic system {i.e. tobacco?
  • Forget about Recession, is USA heading towards a depression? Thoughts?
  • Bush says our economy is "strong" to withstand current crisis? Agree or disagree? Thoughts?
  • Are democrats a bunch of sissies??
  • Do you think the congress allowed the economy to get worse so A Democrat could win the white house?
  • What were the advantages and inconvenients of Taylorism? Fordism?
  • How does fast food contribute to economy's growth of a country?
  • QnAers => I need your opinion on anarcho-communism & capitalism!
  • Breaking News: Yahoo! to reject Microsoft bid.
  • If most Insurance Companies own the Banks, Why are Banks buying Insurance Companies?
  • Under George's watch, is your economy falling down around you?
  • How long has it been since our economy was normal?
  • What do you think about a new AMERICAN IDOL style campaign?
  • What's likely impact of the latest credit crunch related developments on emerging markets like Afric
  • If we went to the barter system, what would you have to offer?
  • How can you compromise when you want to cut back on certain expenses and the other person doesn't