Your Qna     New Questions     About Qna
EQNA is a growing interactive people-knowledge network with more than 120,000 questions and 450,000 answers from over 55,000 members worldwide. With all friendly functions, EQNA will be a fun place to join, share and discover knowledge, an open net space allowing you to connect with other people having specialized knowledge or ones with same interests to yours. EQNA login features secured logins using Twitter and Facebook enable you to place questions without sharing your personal information to us. Lets get out and join our community today!
Ask a Question
MaggieD

Statistics say that eye witness testimony is the least reliable of all. Why is that?

Trina:

Human fallability and the "prejudices" of perspective.

Something I view one way...you view another.

We can be standing only inches apart and watch the same event unfold and yet interpret it differently.

What I see as (for example only) a man struggling with a woman...you may see as a woman struggling with a man....not much difference in what we see but how we view it.

Many times a witness will be asked up to the stand more then once to re-hash their "witnessing"...to go over the same material...and more then likely the "view" will change ever so slightly.

One minute, the man I saw running out of the burning buiding was wearing a red plaid shirt with a black bandanna...but after trying to visualize it some more...I realize that maybe he was wearing a black plaid shirt with a red bandanna??!!!

Our memories are about 75% real and 25% invented by our brain to "fill in the gaps" of the story.

That is why eye witnesses can so easily be "discounted".

MaggieD:

Great answer, Trina. Thank you very much. That makes good sense...especially the part about 75% real/25% invented to fill the gaps. I'm going to remember that.

Mwaldo:

I suppose because individuals focus on different aspects of what they are viewing, and can only remember what they select to remember.

How reliable are statistics though?

MaggieD:

Good point about how reliable stats are. I like your answer, though, it makes sense to me. Thank you very much, Danny!

Ironman:

I think that it is because some people will lie just because they are eye wittnesses, because they dont like one of the people. But that is just what I think.

MaggieD:

And we're all interested in what you think, Caboose. You have some good solid insight. Thank you very much for your answer!

Ironman:

Yay!! people are interested in me!!lol j/k I am already loved by many offline. lol But more people never hurt.

Kks:

Several reasons really, one is selective memory, humans tend to remember the highlights or what they want and some important things get left out, then there is how one percieves a situation, what is relavant to one, isnt to another, and of course many will embellish the scene. They may sometimes swear they seen something that really they didnt see, just to make a good story. Then there is just error. Dates and times when they saw something and things like that.

Popo:

human error.we all remember things differently.certain things give us certain impressions.also others may change the way you remember things.you may also change details the more you think about it.also, memory tends to change over time.

MaggieD:

Very interesting point about memory tending to change over time. Thank you very much for your answer, Nalochic808!

Answer:
Text ColorBackground Color
BoldItalicUnderline
LeftCenterRightJustify
Ordered ListBulleted List
IndentOutdent
Horizontal Rule
SubscriptSuperscript
HyperlinkImage
Design ModeDesign
Html ModeHtml
 

Top Question And Answer

  • trying to find vital statistics for rhode island providence plantations
  • Malaysia statistics on wage inflation or index from 2000 - 2006
  • Where to find statistics on distribution of credit ratings across individuals or businesses
  • How can I get into Clinical Research field with a SAS Certification, one Statistics course?
  • statistics of car accidents in Los Angeles, CA that deal with cell phones????
  • I'm looking for statistics about cell phones and students in U.S, like the penetration rate. Thank
  • eye witness told me color,make & model of car that sideswiped me in sj-any ideas on finding owner?
  • i think i gave a false statement on being a witness to a car accident can i get in trouble
  • What will a Christian "see" when he or she bears record or witness with God and his kingdom?
  • Why must a Christian bear record or witness with God and his kingdom or heaven?
  • When walking through the community, what is the way to witness for our Lord Jesus Christ
  • What is Jehova Witness...and what is their main belief?
  • If you are a Christian, How do people know this? Do you have no testimony you want to share? xo
  • Anyone want to give thier testimony?
  • 7seven7 what is your story or testimony?
  • Should testimony "from beyond the grave" be allowed?
  • Would a refurbished laptop (from a company like Dell) be OK and reliable?
  • information on Summit Health. Are they reliable people to work for? Need to know before i take the j
  • i need some information on dylan rivera who work with reliable industries 7070 airline drive metair
  • Pls refer me to a reliable website to sell an unwanted airline tkt. for 10/16-10/19
  • I am looking info about Reliable Canada who manufactured them in the late '50's to the early 60's?
  • ANY EMPLOYER IN FORT MC MURRAY NEEDS HARD WORKER ?HONEST AND RELIABLE
  • Forget about Recession, is USA heading towards a depression? Thoughts?
  • Bush says our economy is "strong" to withstand current crisis? Agree or disagree? Thoughts?
  • Are democrats a bunch of sissies??
  • Do you think the congress allowed the economy to get worse so A Democrat could win the white house?
  • What were the advantages and inconvenients of Taylorism? Fordism?
  • How does fast food contribute to economy's growth of a country?
  • QnAers => I need your opinion on anarcho-communism & capitalism!
  • Breaking News: Yahoo! to reject Microsoft bid.
  • If most Insurance Companies own the Banks, Why are Banks buying Insurance Companies?
  • Under George's watch, is your economy falling down around you?
  • How long has it been since our economy was normal?
  • What do you think about a new AMERICAN IDOL style campaign?
  • What's likely impact of the latest credit crunch related developments on emerging markets like Afric
  • If we went to the barter system, what would you have to offer?
  • How can you compromise when you want to cut back on certain expenses and the other person doesn't